I feel like singing the song:
Feelings, nothing more than feelings
Trying to forget my feelings of love…
Not because it’s a great song (sorry, but it isn’t). Because through all the verses, the only definite images that come out of it are, well, trite and vague. All we guess is that the singer is sad, and is likely that way because she loved somebody and has to try to “forget” her “feelings of love.”
Excuse me while I gag.
It’s not because I don’t believe in love. Nope. I do think it exists, and I do believe the feelings that come from having love rejected, or losing a loved one, or falling out of love are real.
But feelings without real reasons don’t impress me. Imagine you go home and ask your significant other, “So, how’re you doing?”
The person answers, “I’m sad, actually.”
You ask, “Why?”
“Oh, I don’t know. Just sad.”
You start fishing. “Was work okay?”
“It was fine.”
“The drive?”
“No problem. It was fine, too. Just feeling sad.”
You might even try to help. “Would you like to go out to a movie?”
“Nope. Too sad.”
“Dinner?”
“I’d just cry all the way through it.”
The problem with this scenario is that you can’t really join in the misery. Not because you don’t love the person (or at least like them a lot), but because you have no idea why the other person feels the way he/she does. Nothing motivates you to feel as he/she does.
And THAT is a huge problem. I’ve seen too much of it in writing, too. A woman falls in love with a complete jerk, and you have no idea why. The Mariner shoots the albatross for no reason (although I believe Coleridge had a reason for leaving the motivation out of that poem). People start sobbing in a scene before you can even figure out what’s sad–if the reason is there at all. But all that emotion without the details to justify it can be overwhelming to readers.
So here’s your task:
Create a short piece…a sentence, a few lines of poetry…and within that piece make the feelings clear without a word about what they are. Set the mood, set the feeling, without giving us anything but the reasons, not the dramatic tears, the whining, the dialogue, the words like sad, grateful, wary, cold, etc. Show us the situation, the feelings, without telling us any of it… don’t get inside anyone’s head, don’t name emotions, just show, show, show.
Here’s my example, and most of it will be dialogue (I’m in playwright mode right now):
Dr. Jones moved the plastic apparatus along the cold jelly, pressing it near Emily’s belly button.
“Oh.” His voice sounded soft, like an echo.
“What is it?” Emily asked.
“Um… let me get Nancy. Just a minute.” Dr. Jones left the room, sliding the door shut.
Emily lay back and waited, staring at the window first, then the ceiling when the light began to hurt her eyes. She heard footsteps pad down the hall, a few seconds’ pause, then the footsteps return. Dr. Jones opened the door again, with Nancy bobbing right behind.
“Hey, Emily,” Nancy whispered. “I’m just gonna have a look, okay?” She didn’t wait for Emily’s answer, but pulled the sensor from its hook and placed it on the other side of the navel, swishing jelly along the way. Her eyes stared at the screen, narrowing at one point. She pushed harder, almost digging the plastic into Emily’s abdomen.
“Ouch.”
“Oh, sorry, honey,” Nancy said. She moved the plastic a little, not pressing so hard. Then she leaned back a little, still not taking her eyes off the screen. “How old is the fetus?”
Dr. Jones cleared his throat. “Twelve weeks.”
“Yes,” Emily agreed. “Maybe thirteen.”
Nancy didn’t look at her. “Did you find anything?”
Dr. Jones shook his head. “You?”
Nancy sighed. “No heartbeat.”
“What do you mean?” Emily asked, her voice barely louder than the hum of the machines.
Nancy wiped Emily’s abdomen with a paper towel, then gently covered it with the sheet.
Dr. Jones placed a hand on Emily’s arm. “I’m sorry.”
Only the last word broke the rules… but the situation and likely feelings are clear. The trick is to get your readers to feel a certain way, not just make them watch characters do the feeling. Imagine the same scene if all you saw was Emily at home, sobbing as she told a friend on the phone what had happened, and how sad it made her feel. Far better if we are shown, and not told.
See what you come up with… Blow my own selection out of the water!